• office locations
    Bluffton, SC map
    Bluffton, SC Office
    The Plaza at Belfair
    4 Clarks Summit Drive
    Suite 200 | Bluffton, SC 29910-4993
    843.815.2171  Main | 843.815.5991  Fax
    Charleston, SC map
    Charleston, SC Office
    100 Calhoun Street
    Suite 400 | Charleston, SC 29401
    843.723.7831  Main | 843.722.3227  Fax
    Charlotte, NC map
    Charlotte, NC Office
    Bank of America Plaza
    101 South Tryon Street
    Suite 2610 | Charlotte, NC 28280
    704.347.1170  Main | 704.347.4467  Fax
    Columbia, SC map
    Columbia, SC Office
    1221 Main Street
    Suite 1800 | Columbia, SC 29201
    803.799.9800  Main | 803.753.3278  Fax
    Greenville, SC map
    Greenville, SC Office
    Poinsett Plaza
    104 South Main Street
    Suite 700 | Greenville, SC 29601
    864.271.4940  Main | 864.271.4015  Fax
    Hilton Head Is., SC map
    Hilton Head Island, SC Office
    Shelter Cove Executive Park
    23-B Shelter Cove Lane
    Suite 400 | Hilton Head Island, SC 29928
    843.785.2171  Main | 843.686.5991  Fax
    Myrtle Beach, SC map
    Myrtle Beach, SC Office
    Founders Centre
    2411 Oak Street
    Suite 206 | Myrtle Beach, SC 29577
    843.444.1107  Main | 843.444.4729  Fax
  • contact us
      No   Yes  

News Room


Beverage Systems of the Carolinas: Blue Pencils and Implied ContractsLabor and Employment Law Section of the North Carolina Bar Association
December 18, 2014

Related Information




On August 5, 2014, the North Carolina Court of Appeals issued its most recent decision on the legal enforceability of a non-compete agreement under North Carolina law in the case of Beverage Systems of the Carolinas, LLC v. Associated Beverage Repair, LLC, No. COA14-185, (N.C. App. Aug. 5, 2014). The Court also opined on the contract, or conduct, required to support claims for tortious interference with contract and tortious interference with prospective economic advantage. The court reversed the superior court’s grant of summary judgment to the defendant, which had held the non-compete unenforceable, and remanded to the lower court with directions to “blue pencil” the territory of the non-compete agreement into a reasonable form and hold a trial on whether such revised agreement was breached. The Court also held that the plaintiff’s prior course of ongoing business relations, though not based on a written agreement or other specific terms, was sufficient for tortious interference and related claims.

The majority opinion is authored by Judge Hunter, joined by Judge McGee. Judge Elmore submitted a strongly worded separate dissenting opinion. As of this writing, the appeal is pending before the Supreme Court of North Carolina, and a decision may be expected in the second quarter of 2015. The case of Beverage Systems of the Carolinas, LLC v. Associated Beverage Repair, LLC could become one of the most significant non-compete and business tort cases in North Carolina for many years to come, whether upheld or reversed by the Supreme Court of North Carolina.

To read the full article by Jeremy Stephenson, click here