• office locations
    Bluffton, SC map
    Bluffton, SC Office
    The Plaza at Belfair
    4 Clarks Summit Drive
    Suite 200 | Bluffton, SC 29910-4993
    843.815.2171  Main | 843.815.5991  Fax
    Charleston, SC map
    Charleston, SC Office
    100 Calhoun Street
    Suite 400 | Charleston, SC 29401
    843.723.7831  Main | 843.722.3227  Fax
    Charlotte, NC map
    Charlotte, NC Office
    Bank of America Plaza
    101 South Tryon Street
    Suite 2610 | Charlotte, NC 28280
    704.347.1170  Main | 704.347.4467  Fax
    Columbia, SC map
    Columbia, SC Office
    1221 Main Street
    Suite 1800 | Columbia, SC 29201
    803.799.9800  Main | 803.753.3278  Fax
    Greenville, SC map
    Greenville, SC Office
    Poinsett Plaza
    104 South Main Street
    Suite 700 | Greenville, SC 29601
    864.271.4940  Main | 864.271.4015  Fax
    Hilton Head Is., SC map
    Hilton Head Island, SC Office
    Shelter Cove Executive Park
    23-B Shelter Cove Lane
    Suite 400 | Hilton Head Island, SC 29928
    843.785.2171  Main | 843.686.5991  Fax
    Myrtle Beach, SC map
    Myrtle Beach, SC Office
    Founders Centre
    2411 Oak Street
    Suite 206 | Myrtle Beach, SC 29577
    843.444.1107  Main | 843.444.4729  Fax
  • contact us
      No   Yes  

News Room


SC Court Says "No" to NLRB Posting RuleApril 17, 2012

Related Information




The Chamber of Commerce of the United States and the South Carolina Chamber of Commerce (“Chambers”) filed a lawsuit seeking review of a final rule promulgated by the National Labor Relations Board (“NLRB” or “the Board”). For over seventy-five years, the NLRB was one of a very few federal labor agencies that did not require employers to post a general notice of employee rights in the workplace.

On December 22, 2010, the Board decided that it would change from its 75 year history and issued a proposed rule: all employers subject to the National Labor Relations Act (“NLRA” or “the Act”) must post notices informing employees of their rights under the NLRA. After completing a notice and comment period/process, the Board published a final rule on August 30, 2011. After a number of extensions, the rule was set to take effect on April 30, 2012.

United States District Court Judge David Norton reviewed the rule in extensive briefings from the Chambers and the NLRB. Judge Norton determined that the Chambers’ position was the correct position – the Board, in promulgating the final rule exceeded its authority in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act.

Judge Norton’s opinion provides a thorough review of the Act, the purposes of the Act, and how rule making should be performed under the Administrative Procedure Act, as he carefully addressed the issues before him. He also looked at other labor statutes and part of his very detailed analysis was a comparison chart of other federal labor and employment statutes' posting requirements with that of the NLRA. Interestingly, the three Acts that generally comprise the NLRA (the Wagner Act, along with the Taft-Hartley and Landrum-Griffin Amendments) contain no statutory mandate to post any notice as required by the NLRA’s rule. Other statutes such as Title VII, ADEA, OSHA, FMLA and others contain specific statutory authority requiring that employers post notices outlining rights and remedies under those statutes.

Judge Norton, as he had with the detailed discussion of the Act, went through the applicable case law in a statutory construction case. He found that the plain language of the Act “compelled” a finding that the Board lacked the authority under the Act’s language to promulgate the rule.

The Court’s conclusions can be summed up as follows:

1.    The rule is “useful” but “not necessary” to carry out the provisions of the NLRA;
2.    The NLRB is an agency that reacts to charges filed by others and the rule “proactively dictates employer conduct prior to the filing of any petition or charge;” and
3.    There was no statutory “gap” for the NLRB to fill.

Additional Information

McNair Law Firm has experienced attorneys who focus on various aspects of the law including litigation, tax, and corporate law. If you have any questions about this news alert, please contact Rick Morgan or any of our attorneys on our website at www.mcnair.net.

This Alert provides an overview of certain aspects of a specific legal issue. It is not intended to be, and should not be construed as, legal advice for any particular fact situation. This Alert does not establish and should not be construed as establishing an attorney client relationship.

Richard J. Morgan, Shareholder
1221 Main Street
Columbia, SC 29201

Jeremy A. Stephenson, Special Counsel
301 South Tryon Street, Suite 1615
Charlotte, NC 28282